18 November 2026

Always-on, AI search and tracking: your digital marketing questions answered

When 150 people joined our webinar on what to start, stop and continue in digital marketing, the questions came in faster than we could answer them. Mike from IFF Digital gave a clear, practical steer, and the Q&A that followed covered everything from budgets and tracking to AI search and what to post on YouTube.

Here is a round-up of those questions, including the ones we did not have time for on the day, which Mike answered by email afterwards. The big idea running through all of it is simple: parents are researching schools all year round, so the schools that do best are always visible, well measured and working as one team across marketing and admissions.

Always-on campaigns and budgets

The most common theme was what "always-on" really means in practice. Mike's starting point was a trap many schools fall into: running paid campaigns only around open days and deadlines. It is easy to budget for, but every time a campaign is paused on Google or Meta, the platform goes back into its learning phase and the optimisation built up over previous weeks is lost.

In Mike's analysis, the average cost per click for independent school open day searches was around £3.45 at the October and November peak, against around £1.53 across the rest of the year. Schools advertising only at peak can pay up to six times more for the same click.

Does "always-on" mean a bigger budget?

No. Mike was clear that the aim is to spend the budget you have more efficiently, not to spend more. You can phase it to follow seasonality, entry point (day, boarding, international) and your own priorities. Google and Meta can both show you seasonality for your own school.

If you are making the case for a budget, Mike suggested working backwards from enrolments. If you are asking for £60,000 and a pupil brings in £30,000 in annual fees, the digital activity only needs to add two pupils to pay for itself. It is a crude, top-level sum, but it puts the conversation in terms that heads and bursars understand.

Does a new campaign reset the learning?

One member asked whether adding a new campaign resets things, and whether it is better to keep one campaign running and just update the ad assets. Mike's answer was to keep one campaign running with no end date and refresh the creative inside it. On both Google and Meta, a campaign builds up learning over time. Ending a campaign and starting a new one throws that learning away, and pausing can send it back into learning too. Running several short campaigns side by side does not solve this, and it can spread your budget and data too thin.

Instead, keep a permanent campaign for each key audience or stage, for example Pre-Prep, Senior and Sixth Form. Rotate fresh ads and assets within it, and make changes gradually rather than all at once.

Should Meta be always-on too?

Yes. Meta works in the same way as Google: it needs data to learn, and learning depends on budget. A learning phase can take up to around two weeks, so a four-week burst ahead of an open day spends half its life learning, and then the cycle resets when you pause.

How should we split budget between Google and Meta?

For the schools Mike works with, the typical starting point is around 70% Google and 30% Meta. He stressed that every school is different. A discovery phase, reviewing current performance, objectives and gaps, should shape the split and how it is phased across the year by channel.

Is there a benchmark for a yearly digital budget?

There is no single figure, as it depends on the school. Mike did describe how schools further along the journey think about it: customer lifetime value. A pupil who joins in prep and stays to sixth form is worth more than one who joins at 16, so a school may be willing to pay a higher cost per enquiry or enrolment for them. The same applies to boarders compared with day pupils.

Tracking and measurement

Our live polls showed how big this issue is. When we asked whether attendees could track an enrolment back to the marketing channel that drove the enquiry, only 9% said yes for most enrolments. Almost half said it was patchy, and 23% said the data stops at the website. Mike named limited tracking as one of the two most common roadblocks he sees, alongside a fragmented website journey.

We use a third-party admissions portal. Can we still track enquiries through to enrolments?

Yes, in a realistic way, and without replacing the system. If your portal sits separately from your website, you can add tagging to the portal link, so that a click out to the portal counts as a conversion. You cannot see what happens beyond it, but it tells you the campaign drove someone with high intent to the portal.

To go a step further, most portals, such as iSAMS, OpenApply and Metis, have a registration form with a final success page. If you can get that page from your portal provider, it becomes your conversion point, and you can feed it back to the ad platforms. The same applies to open day forms, which usually end on a thank-you page that can be tracked in analytics and Google Tag Manager.

How do you feed tracking back to Google?

By linking Google Ads to Google Analytics. When conversion data flows from GA4 into Google Ads, Google can optimise towards the people most likely to convert for your school. Without it, you are optimising towards platform data only, which is still useful but performs less well. Mike said this is possible and is being done for many schools now.

Do we need a CRM to help with tracking?

It is not essential. What matters is being able to track marketing activity to a conversion point on the site or the admissions portal, and report on it. Whatever sits in the middle does not matter much, as long as the right tagging can be added. If you already have a CRM, such as HubSpot, you are probably halfway there.

What comes first: a new website or digital marketing?

They are part of the same stream, and Mike's order of work is clear. First, fix measurement, because you should not put budget into media if you cannot measure it. Second, fix your organic footprint: your SEO foundations, site structure, technical set-up and content. If you have a small internal team, there are quick wins, such as updating page titles and metadata.

PMax

PMax is Google's AI-led campaign type. It lets a school run one campaign across Search, YouTube, Display, Discovery, Gmail and Maps, and Mike called it a game changer for the schools he works with. It is not keyword-based. Instead it looks for signals and intent, and you feed it as many signals as you can.

What minimum budget do you need?

Mike did not have a figure to hand. His general advice is to stick to the minimum daily budgets the platforms recommend, because they are there for a reason, and the more data you feed a platform, the faster it learns. If you are going to test PMax, he suggested ring-fencing around three months of budget, getting tracking in place first, and agreeing a minimum budget and timeframe up front. Three months gives you enough data to make informed decisions.

Our agency has recommended no PMax, and our open events campaign is limited by budget. What should we do?

Without seeing the account, Mike could not say for certain. He would, however, recommend testing PMax alongside existing Search campaigns rather than ruling it out. Search ads on their own only reach parents who are actively searching on Google at that moment, which is a small share of the market at any one time, often called the 3% who are in market. For one of IFF Digital's education clients, PMax drove 10 times the enquiries at an 87% lower cost per enquiry.

On the budget limit, a campaign marked "limited by budget" does not always need more money. It is often worth checking keyword targeting, bid strategy and how budget is shared between campaigns first.

What does a digital campaign for an open morning look like?

Mike shared a recent example for a school with an October open morning:

  1. Google Search: standard pay-per-click targeting keywords such as "private schools near me".
  2. PMax: a campaign built on signals and intent, aimed at anyone in market for or attending an open day with an interest in independent schools.
  3. Meta: ads on Facebook, plus an in-app lead generation campaign, so people can sign up with a very short form without leaving the app.
  4. A clear call to action: to book an open day, with visitors sent to a sign-up form on the website.

The school then measured sign-ups and talked to admissions about how many of those people attended and went on to enrol, so spend could be tied to real outcomes.

AI search, traffic and content

Every school Mike speaks to is asking about AI, and members were no different. His message was consistent: do not do everything for AI. Get the foundations right first, because research from Searchable and Similarweb found around an 80% overlap between the brands AI tools cite and the brands that rank strongly in organic search.

Our head keeps asking what we are doing about ChatGPT and AI search. Where do we start?

Mike's advice is to start with the fundamentals, in three steps:

  1. Check your technical foundations. Is your site accessible, structured, fast and scalable? One school he spoke to had much of its content locked in PDFs, which neither large language models nor Google can read.
  2. Review your content. Is it genuinely useful, where are the gaps, and where are you and your competitors visible?
  3. Build a measurement framework. That lets you show senior teams where you started, where the gaps are and how you will track progress.

Are website visitor numbers falling now that large language models are "stealing" traffic?

Across the schools Mike works with, overall visitor numbers are broadly steady year on year. What has changed is how parents arrive. Click-through rates from traditional organic search results are dropping, and direct traffic is affected too, while visits and referrals from AI platforms such as ChatGPT are growing. That is why a joined-up, cross-channel approach matters, along with measurement that lets you attribute enquiries to the right channel.

Do social posts with keywords help SEO?

Not directly, though they may help indirectly. Your SEO comes mainly from your website, because Google crawls the site for keywords and relevant information. Large language models draw on a wider range of sources for their citations, so social content can help there. For organic search, make sure your site content is optimised and your data is well structured.

What should we post on YouTube, and should we post shorts?

Behind-the-scenes content, pupil voice and anything that shows what makes your school different. Mike said any video content is worth posting, because large language models need sources of information and a lot of it comes from social platforms. He also flagged Reddit as a growing source of citations in AI tools.

On shorts, the answer was a definite yes. Upload them organically to YouTube Shorts to build reach for free, and use the same videos as ad assets in PMax or Demand Gen campaigns, so Google can show them across YouTube, including Shorts, alongside Search, Display and Gmail.

Are hashtags still relevant?

Mike thinks so. A few people still search by hashtag, and emojis are also helping engagement for many schools. His advice was to test both, as neither is against best practice.

How should we handle AI-manipulated images and photos of children?

More and more schools are moving to group shots instead of images of individual children. The schools Mike works with also say their own internal surveys show parents are more comfortable with group shots.

Agencies, budgets and building the case for investment

What proportion of budget should go on an agency's fee compared with media?

There is no set percentage. Mike said agencies usually take one of two models: a percentage of media spend, or a fixed management fee. IFF Digital prefers a fixed fee, because a percentage of media can encourage an agency to push you to spend more rather than spend efficiently.

More useful than a ratio are the questions to ask:

  • How many channels is the agency managing?
  • How much hands-on campaign management do you get?
  • How often do they report and meet with you?
  • Do they help fix tracking and reporting problems, which is the biggest barrier to proving return on investment for most schools?

It is a partnership. The agency needs enough budget to do its best work, and you need to ring-fence enough media budget to show real commercial results. Mike suggested asking for a monthly media plan that shows spend, the management fee and what that spend is expected to deliver in enquiries, enrolments and fee return, so you have a business case to take back to your school.

What can we do if there is no marketing department at all?

This was one of the most heartfelt questions, from a school where admissions deals only with the practicalities of enrolling and a new recruitment team has no marketing budget. Mike's advice was to lean on the sector, learn from events like this one, and build a business case for modest marketing investment, particularly if enrolment is declining or demand is weakening. Many schools have relied on word of mouth and referrals, but the sector is more competitive and the pool is shrinking, so the schools that stand out and are present at every stage of the parent journey are more likely to be chosen.

He also pointed out that many heads have no idea this data exists. A meeting where you can show what is available, and forecast what an investment could return, can be a turning point. Whoever you are, you are not on your own: a growing number of schools are making this case and finding greater buy-in from heads.

Watch the full webinar

If you would like the full picture, the recording, a summary with suggested action points and a complete transcript, including every question above, are available to AMCIS members on AMCIS Connect.

Watch the webinar and download the notes

Not a member yet? Sign up in just a few minutes to gain access to all our resources and more.

Thank you to Mike and the team at IFF Digital for such a practical session, and to everyone who joined and asked questions.

Related topics